Good Company

Trupanion Lifts Profit in Q3 While Lemonade's Pet Claims Costs Climb

Both US pet insurers grew in the third quarter of 2026, but Trupanion turned growth into record adjusted operating income while Lemonade's pet book grew 53 percent and its pet loss ratio rose to 75 percent.

By Good Company Editorial Desk

Trupanion logo

The News

Two different models for selling pet insurance produced two different third quarters, and GlobalPETS put them side by side on November 13, 2026. Trupanion, the Seattle based specialist that sells medical insurance for cats and dogs, grew revenue more slowly and made more money from it. Lemonade, the digital insurer that sells pet cover alongside renters, homeowners and car insurance, grew its pet book far faster and paid more out in pet claims.

Trupanion reported third quarter results on November 5, 2026 for the quarter ended September 30, 2026. Total revenue was $405.6 million, up 11 percent from a year earlier. Revenue from its subscription business, its core monthly plans, was $287.9 million, up 14 percent. Net income was $9.3 million, or $0.21 per basic and diluted share, up from $5.9 million, or $0.13 per diluted share, a year earlier. The company said it was its sixth consecutive quarter of positive net income in earnings call coverage of the results, and its adjusted operating income reached a record $47 million, up 15 percent.

Lemonade reported its third quarter the same week. Total company revenue was $336.1 million, up 73 percent year over year, and gross profit rose 48 percent to $118.1 million. The pet part of that story is in force premium, the annualized value of premiums for policies in force at quarter end. Pet in force premium reached $603 million, up 53 percent from $394 million a year earlier, and pet was the largest single piece of Lemonade's total in force premium of $1.551 billion, at about 39 percent. Premium per pet customer rose 9 percent to $854, from $782 a year earlier, according to GlobalPETS.

The cost side moved the other way. GlobalPETS reported that Lemonade's pet segment gross loss ratio rose to 75 percent, from 71 percent a year earlier. Lemonade's overall gross loss ratio also rose, to 65 percent from 62 percent, and the company posted a net loss of $43.7 million for the quarter, wider than $37.5 million a year earlier, even as its adjusted EBITDA loss narrowed.

Why It Matters

Pet insurance is where rising veterinary costs stop being an abstract trend and become a line item. An insurer collects a monthly premium and pays clinic invoices when pets get sick or hurt. If clinic prices rise faster than premiums, the loss ratio climbs and the growth that looked attractive gets expensive. That is the tension in Lemonade's quarter: pet premiums up 53 percent is a striking growth number, and a 75 percent pet loss ratio says a large share of that premium is going straight back out to pay claims.

Trupanion's quarter shows the specialist answer to the same pressure. The company added more than 20,500 net new subscription pets in the quarter, up more than 28 percent from a year earlier, while its average pet acquisition cost fell to $279 from $290, which the company attributed largely to improved conversion. Monthly average revenue per pet was $88.95, up 8 percent. Retention improved for a seventh consecutive quarter, according to the company. In plain terms, Trupanion is raising what each enrolled pet brings in, spending a little less to enroll each new pet, and keeping members longer. That combination is what turned 11 percent revenue growth into record adjusted operating income.

The two companies also reach pet owners differently. Trupanion says it is the only North American provider with technology to pay veterinarians directly in seconds at checkout, and it works through veterinary hospitals as a core channel. Lemonade sells digitally as part of a multi product household wallet, with 3.52 million customers across all products, up 23 percent, and it highlighted its AI based platform, Lemonade OS, as the engine behind 25 new product and geography combinations launched during 2026, according to GlobalPETS.

"Our third-quarter results were strong, with record cash flow and increased profitability, the seventh consecutive quarter of improvement in retention, and continued progress on our key strategic initiatives," said Margi Tooth, Chief Executive Officer and President of Trupanion, in the company's results release. "As our business continues to compound, we are investing with discipline in organic growth, and this quarter we also repurchased approximately $25 million of our stock."

The Numbers

  • Trupanion Q3 2026 total revenue: $405.6 million, up 11 percent year over year (quarter ended September 30, 2026)
  • Trupanion subscription revenue: $287.9 million, up 14 percent; nine month subscription revenue $834.0 million, up 15 percent
  • Trupanion adjusted operating income: $47 million, up 15 percent, described in earnings coverage as a record
  • Trupanion net income: $9.3 million, or $0.21 per share, up from $5.9 million, or $0.13 per diluted share, a year earlier
  • Trupanion free cash flow: $28.5 million, up from $23.9 million a year earlier; operating cash flow $30.7 million
  • Trupanion subscription enrolled pets: 1,145,160 at September 30, 2026, up 6 percent; total enrolled pets 1,626,901, down 2 percent
  • Trupanion net new subscription pets in Q3: more than 20,500, up more than 28 percent year over year
  • Trupanion average pet acquisition cost: $279, down from $290 a year earlier; monthly average revenue per pet $88.95, up 8 percent
  • Trupanion share repurchases in Q3: about 0.8 million shares for about $25 million, with about $75 million still available under the program
  • Lemonade Q3 2026 total revenue: $336.1 million, up 73 percent; gross profit $118.1 million, up 48 percent
  • Lemonade pet in force premium: $603 million, up 53 percent from $394 million a year earlier, about 39 percent of total in force premium of $1.551 billion, up 34 percent
  • Lemonade premium per pet customer: $854, up 9 percent from $782 a year earlier, per GlobalPETS
  • Lemonade pet gross loss ratio: 75 percent, up from 71 percent a year earlier, per GlobalPETS; overall gross loss ratio 65 percent, up from 62 percent
  • Lemonade customers across all products: 3.52 million, up 23 percent; Q3 net loss $43.7 million, wider than $37.5 million a year earlier

What It Means For You

If you run a veterinary clinic, read these two quarters as a map of who will be sitting across from your clients at checkout. A specialist that pays at the point of care and a digital insurer whose pet book is now its largest premium pool are both getting bigger, which means insured clients are a growing share of the pets in your waiting room either way. The practical move is to know, by insurer, how claims, approvals and direct pay actually work in your practice management system, so coverage helps a treatment conversation instead of slowing it down.

If you sell pet health, wellness or chronic care products, the loss ratio is your signal. Insurers paying 75 cents of every pet premium dollar in claims have a direct financial interest in anything that credibly prevents, catches earlier or better manages expensive conditions. The buyer on the other side of the table now has a published cost problem to solve, not just a nice story about healthier pets.

If you are a founder or marketer competing for the same pet owner, note where the growth is coming from. Trupanion grew by improving conversion, retention and revenue per pet on a base it already had. Lemonade grew pet premium 53 percent while spending more on marketing and acquisition, and told investors it expects in force premium growth to outpace growth spending from the fourth quarter onward. One model compounds quietly; the other buys scale and then has to prove the claims math works. Be explicit about which game you are playing.

What To Watch

Watch Lemonade's pet loss ratio in the fourth quarter and into 2027. The company raised its full year 2026 revenue outlook to $1.231 billion to $1.235 billion after the quarter and expects fourth quarter revenue of $342 million to $346 million. If pet claims costs stay at the third quarter level while the company tries to slow growth spending, pricing, plan design or both will have to move.

Watch Trupanion's outlook delivery. The company expects full year 2026 total revenue of $1.590 billion to $1.597 billion, subscription revenue of $1.131 billion to $1.133 billion, and adjusted operating income of $179 million to $182 million, up about 19 percent at the midpoint. It also expects fourth quarter revenue of $407 million to $414 million. Hitting that range while total enrolled pets are down 2 percent would confirm that the business is now growing mainly through its subscription core, not its other business segment.

Watch veterinary cost inflation itself, because both stories run through it. Lemonade's earnings discussion linked the pet pressure to rising veterinary costs, and Trupanion's revenue per pet gains are the other side of the same invoice. If clinic prices keep rising faster than household budgets, insurance becomes more attractive to owners and harder to price for insurers at the same time.

Sources

  • GlobalPETS, "Trupanion lifts profits while Lemonade faces higher claims costs," November 13, 2026, updated November 14, 2026: https://globalpetindustry.com/news/trupanion-lifts-profits-while-lemonade-faces-higher-claims-costs/
  • Trupanion, "Trupanion Reports Third Quarter 2026 Results," November 5, 2026: https://s29.q4cdn.com/621138337/files/doc_financials/2026/q3/Trupanion-Earnings-Release-Q3-2026.pdf
  • Trupanion, Third Quarter 2026 Earnings Call Prepared Remarks, November 5, 2026: https://s29.q4cdn.com/621138337/files/content_files/Trupanion-Q3-2026-Prepared-Remarks.pdf
  • Beinsure, "Insurtech Lemonade Q3 revenue jumps 73% to $336 mn as IFP premiums reach $1.55 bn," November 2026: https://beinsure.com/news/insurtech-lemonade-q3-revenue-336mn/
  • Lemonade Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript, November 5, 2026, via The Motley Fool: https://www.fool.com/earnings/call-transcripts/2026/11/06/lemonade-lmnd-q3-2026-earnings-call-transcript/